Friday, September 9, 2011

Muted Reaction to Jobs Plan

Last night the president laid out a $447 billion jobs plan which includes continuing the holidays on some existing tax cuts as well as adding some new employer-side cuts. More than half of the plan is focused on tax cuts while another $105 billion goes to infrastructure renovations including school modernization, transportation projects and rehabilitation of vacant properties.  

Payroll tax cuts are the plan’s central focus. It calls for reducing payroll taxes on the first $106,800 of individual earnings and is split evenly between employers and employees. It reduces the portion paid by workers next year to 3.1% from 6.2%. The current deal set to expire this year reduces payroll taxes by 2%.  

The best part is that businesses get the same 3.1% reduction on taxes they pay on the first $5 million of their payroll. The benefits are aimed squarely at small businesses that create most of America’s jobs. Additionally, the full 6.2% of the employer contribution can be waived on the first $50 million net increase in a company’s payroll, covering raises and new positions.

A study released yesterday is bound to get some attention as the Congress takes up the president’s job bill. The Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation reports revealed in stark terms that net US job growth occurs only  through startup firms. The study entitled The Importance of Startups in Job Creation and Job Destruction, bases its findings on the Business Dynamics Statistics, a U.S. government dataset compiled by the U.S. Census Bureau. It reveals that, both on average and for all but seven years between 1977 and 2005, existing firms are net job destroyers, losing 1 million jobs net combined per year. By contrast, in their first year, new firms add an average of 3 million jobs. And remarkably, during recessionary years, job creation at startups remains stable, while net job losses at existing firms are highly sensitive to the business cycle.

 The study’s author, Tim Kane says that because startups, that develop organically, are almost solely the drivers of job growth, job-creation policies aimed at luring larger, established employers will inevitably fail. Such city and state policies are doomed not only because they are zero-sum, but because they are based in unrealistic employment growth models. Expect to see some dramatic changes in the way states and municipalities lure new business. 

While there was no good news on the jobs front, other economic reports this week were, on balance, more positive, and argued against the double dip threat. The Institute for Supply Management said their non-manufacturing composite moved six tenths higher to 53.3, which stands in stark contrast to the dearth of bad news in August. A reading above 50 indicates monthly growth and, because it is slightly higher than July, it also indicates acceleration in growth as the Christmas season approaches.  

Bloomberg reported that the Fed’s Beige Book prepared for the September 20-21 FOMC meeting indicates that there is no double-dip recession and that the economy continues to expand, although at a "modest pace." The report largely confirmed generally accepted assumptions regarding the economy. Consumer spending is limping along, largely on motor vehicle sales. Manufacturing is growing but at a slower pace than earlier in the year. Housing is still flat and depressed. Commercial real estate and construction activity is weak or little changed, but improvements were noted in several areas. Labor markets were generally steady, although some districts reported modest employment growth. As for inflation, the majority of districts reported fewer price pressures, but input costs continued to rise in select industries.

Exports rebounded a whopping 3.6% in July after dropping 2.2% in June reducing the nation’s trade gap from $51.6 billion to $44.8 billion. All three major components of petroleum, non-petroleum, and services shrank. The report was good news for manufacturers and for third quarter GDP. 

Whether the economy falls back into recession or continues at its current sluggish pace, job creation is not likely. Economists suggest that growth of at least 3 – 3.5% is required to create jobs at a pace capable of putting the nation’s 10% to 17% un- and under-employed back to work. The best instant polling available is provided by the capital markets and in short, investors see no catalyst in the president’s plan capable of providing that kind of jolt to the economy. As of this writing, the MSCI Total US Market Index is down 1.2% at 10:00 a.m. The S&P 500 is down 1.4%. The 7-10 year Treasury index is up .2%.

The president said last night there is no silver bullet, no quick fix for the mess this economy is in. While he is to be commended for specificity and a bipartisan spirit, his plan simply fell short of providing the kind of impact required to break the inertia, to inspire innovation and risk-taking. Temporary tax breaks infrastructure builds simply do not light entrepreneurial fires.  

Bold measures are needed and speeches before joint sessions of Congress are a great place to launch them. Here are just a few ideas we didn’t hear enough of. Clean and flatten the tax code and make it permanent. Pledge to stop using it as a political tool. Reduce regulations and pledge a leaner simpler regulatory environment for new and growing businesses. Allow corporations to bring their offshore profits home without taxes if they build domestic plants and create American jobs with the money. Fix Social Security by lengthening the retirement age, means-testing it, and ending the ability of Congress to tap it to ‘balance’ their budgets. Fix Medicare by giving the states more administrative authority, putting the patient back in control, and forcing insurance companies to compete.  

As the ball is passed to the Congress and to the elite group of six, we wait to see if our government of the people has what it takes to come up with ‘bold measures.’ Put simply, the reduction of the size and scope of their dominion. Can they possibly do this? Judging when and where the applause came from last night, one would seriously doubt the possibility. Unfortunately, failure to bring bold measures potentially means years and even decades of stagnation and growth well below American potential.

Friday, September 2, 2011

Strategists Like Stocks, Despite the Economy

If you have any exposure at all to the US economy, whether you run a corporation or you are raising money for the school PTA, you have no doubt noticed a certain reservation among people to spend, invest, or give their money. August proved a tough month for the economy. Confidence crushers such as the debt ceiling debate, the unprecedented downgrade of US Treasuries from AAA to AA+ by Standard & Poor’s, a plunging stock market, an earthquake strong enough to suggest attack for many in DC and NY, and an east coast hurricane that literally quieted the “city that never sleeps” all fueled a growing sense of pessimism.  

The Conference Board reported earlier this week that confidence plummeted 14.7 points in August to 44.5, the lowest reading since April 2009. Consumer expectations for employment, business conditions and income all fell. The expectations index, at 51.9, is also at its lowest level since April 2009. Mild positives in the report were gains in plans to buy cars and major appliances, but purchase plans for homes fell sharply.  

The National Association of Realtors said that pending home sales declined 1.3% in July after a 2.4% increase the prior month. However the good news was that signings to buy new homes increased 14.4% in July. And home prices may be stabilizing. The Case-Shiller 10—city index showed that home price declines ended June were unchanged for a second month (three month average). On a year ago basis, prices are down 3.9%. 

The stalwart US manufacturing sector continues to buttress the economy. Perhaps the data will indicate slowing in the coming weeks, but for now, the lonely champion of the US economy resists the malaise. The ISM Manufacturing composite index edged only three tenths lower in August to a reading of 50.6. The reading above 50 indicates monthly expansion in general activity, but it is relatively slow. Job creation was blamed for holding this month’s number down. Today the government announced that the unemployment rate remained steady at 9.1%. 

However, once the economy turns, job creation may improve. It appears that companies have squeezed about as much productivity from their current lean workforces as they may be able to get. Nonfarm productivity fell an annualized 0.7%, compared to the original estimate of a 0.3% dip and a 0.6% decrease in the first quarter. The drop is also attributed to a revised more sluggish rise in output of 1.3%. But businesses may have to pay more for workers. The report showed that unit labor costs increased by a revised 3.3% in the second quarter, compared to an initial estimate of 2.2%.  

August was a tough month for stock indexes which fell about 16% as measured by the S&P 500 index. The 9% recovery since then has seemingly done little to quell fears of further declines. The State Street Investor Confidence index fell from 102.5 in July to 89.6 by August’s end. A reading below 100 indicates demand for safety relative to risk. The report attributes the flight to safety to diminished growth expectations, the US downgrade, and continued sovereign troubles in Europe.

Strategists Expect 16% Rally by Year End 

Bloomberg says that “Wall Street has never been [surer] that the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index will rally in 2011, even after speculation the US economy is heading for a recession prompted the biggest plunge since the bull market began.” The Bloomberg survey of 13 chief bank strategists forecast the index rise to an average of 1,401 (16%) by year’s end. That estimate did not budge in August.  

Strategists say that earnings growth will fuel the gains they expect. The survey reveals that S&P 500 profit will rise 18% in 2011 and 14% in 2012. With almost all of the S&P’s 500 companies reporting for the second quarter earnings season, more than 75% of them exceeded their earnings estimates, with total income topping projections by 5.2%.  

Bloomberg says that investors are paying less for equities than they have during every recession since Ronald Reagan was president amid growing concern that the economy is on the edge of another recession. With the 13% drop in the S&P 500 in the past five weeks, the price-to-earnings ratio has fallen to 12.9, 3.5% less than the average multiple during the 10 contractions since 1949 and a level last reached in 1982. 

If another recession is ahead, stocks may stay cheap for a while longer. But if corporations continue to grow their earnings or even maintain them at current levels, stock prices will almost certainly rise. If you are a long term investor, take heart, all the cash sloshing around in this economy will eventually find a home where it will be treated best; and historically that’s common stocks.

Friday, August 26, 2011

Few Offsets to the Negative Drift

Today, the government revised its assessment of the US economy’s growth for the second quarter downward more than economists expected this morning. GDP grew at only 1%, down from a previous estimate of 1.3% in July.  But the underlying numbers were more positive. Final sales of domestic product improved to a 1.1% annualized rate from 0.0% in the first quarter. Capital expenditures were revised to 7.9% from 5.7% and non-residential fixed investment was revised to 15.7% from 8.1%.  

The Bureau of Economic Analysis reported today that corporate profits in the second quarter rose only 3.3% annualized after a 39.9% surge the quarter before. Corporate profits are unchanged on a year-on-year basis, compared to up 2.8% in the first quarter.  

The manufacturing sector, which has kept the economy afloat, offered some more good news earlier in the week. The Chicago Fed's national activity index improved to minus 0.06 from an upwardly revised minus 0.38 in June. The three-month moving average improved sharply in July, to minus 0.29 from minus 0.54 (upwardly revised from minus 0.60), according to Bloomberg.  

Retail sales during the August 20 week slowed to an annualized 3.6% rate, ending a three-week run of rates over 4%. Housing continues to sink. Last week's report on existing home sales showed surprising contraction. This week, it was reported that new home sales dropped 0.7% for the month. Prices of both existing and new homes contracted in July by a steep 6.3%.  

An increasing number of economists and analysts are joining the chorus that we are headed for recession or are already in one. The S&P 500 has risen 3.2% in the past four days, possibly posting the first weekly advance in five weeks. Traders believe that Fed policy makers will act to support growth. It is almost certain that they will be disappointed. There are strong dissenting voices on the FOMC against current policy, so further easing will meet resistance. Besides, rates cannot go much lower. 

The Great Depression was made significantly worse by errant fiscal and monetary policies. The Smoot Hawley Act raised tariffs on imports and trade that caused a global trade war essentially shutting down international commerce when it was needed most. This time, we find that it is the void of policy guidance that threatens the economic health of the country and, therefore, the world.  

The failure of the executive and legislative branches to spell out the direction of taxes, regulations, and entitlements are becoming powerful dis-incentives to growth. Businesses are communicating loudly and clearly that they will not hire nor will they substantially invest in new plant or equipment until they have a much clearer and longer-term picture of what it will cost in taxes and regulations to do business in this country. With a presidential election relatively close, politics weigh heavily against the possibility of meaningful compromise before the next election, but it is possible. 

For now, there appear to be few economic catalysts to growth beyond what policymakers have within their power to offer; if they will. The recipe is pretty simple: tax reform aimed at providing a simpler, flatter, lower, and dramatically more uniformly applied code (free of loopholes), reduction and streamlining of regulations, and the biggie – entitlement reform. But odds of passage of anything remotely effective emerging amidst the current political climate seem infinitesimally small. But hope springs eternal. 

 Time to return to hurricane preparation. Stay safe this weekend.